We do a mix of all of these. We do a bunch of discussing, and if it looks like there might be a consensus, that's great and we do with that.
But then when we get to voting, in addition to voting for top choices, we vote "above the line" vs "below the line". Where, roughly above the line means you think they should get an offer either firs…
We do a mix of all of these. We do a bunch of discussing, and if it looks like there might be a consensus, that's great and we do with that.
But then when we get to voting, in addition to voting for top choices, we vote "above the line" vs "below the line". Where, roughly above the line means you think they should get an offer either first, or when other people ahead of them turn offers down. "Below the line" means you'd rather not make them an offer, even if others have turned offers down (basically, you'd prefer the search to fail to making an offer to the candidate). But then we'll often do further rounds of discussion after learning opinions about the line.
We do a mix of all of these. We do a bunch of discussing, and if it looks like there might be a consensus, that's great and we do with that.
But then when we get to voting, in addition to voting for top choices, we vote "above the line" vs "below the line". Where, roughly above the line means you think they should get an offer either first, or when other people ahead of them turn offers down. "Below the line" means you'd rather not make them an offer, even if others have turned offers down (basically, you'd prefer the search to fail to making an offer to the candidate). But then we'll often do further rounds of discussion after learning opinions about the line.