Thank you so much for this angle of the discussion that people often ignore, what I wanted to comment on whether context makes a difference (on East-West axis) In Islam, some say it is a duty for a muslim to give advice about doing good, and avoiding misdeeds El-Ammr bel Ma'rof wa El-Nahy A'n El-Monkr "الأمر بالمعروف و النهي عن المنكر" a…
Thank you so much for this angle of the discussion that people often ignore, what I wanted to comment on whether context makes a difference (on East-West axis) In Islam, some say it is a duty for a muslim to give advice about doing good, and avoiding misdeeds El-Ammr bel Ma'rof wa El-Nahy A'n El-Monkr "الأمر بالمعروف و النهي عن المنكر" any time which might give a permission to exercise a moral restrainting over others' actions (especially in the case of women by men). A lot of time, this topic is brought up in my country (Egypt) about the appropriateness of giving advice for women on fb groups or in public (previously) from islamic teachings, online now some people even post anonymously (so we do not know the gender of the advisor so we cannot say it is men exercising a domineering role over women), but what strikes me is that some of these women vigorously attack this person as if he is sort of hypocrite or even trying to fit a patricharal role, and why he is not spending talking about this and this, but a lot of these women will not contest what he says on theological grounds (because they have not studied this) nor whether they geniuely accept Islam or not (or consider themselves true muslims according to commonly held teachings or not or even aspire to be), they just refuse to lose the fruits of women's liberalization. So what do you think about this issue for instance?
Thank you so much for this angle of the discussion that people often ignore, what I wanted to comment on whether context makes a difference (on East-West axis) In Islam, some say it is a duty for a muslim to give advice about doing good, and avoiding misdeeds El-Ammr bel Ma'rof wa El-Nahy A'n El-Monkr "الأمر بالمعروف و النهي عن المنكر" any time which might give a permission to exercise a moral restrainting over others' actions (especially in the case of women by men). A lot of time, this topic is brought up in my country (Egypt) about the appropriateness of giving advice for women on fb groups or in public (previously) from islamic teachings, online now some people even post anonymously (so we do not know the gender of the advisor so we cannot say it is men exercising a domineering role over women), but what strikes me is that some of these women vigorously attack this person as if he is sort of hypocrite or even trying to fit a patricharal role, and why he is not spending talking about this and this, but a lot of these women will not contest what he says on theological grounds (because they have not studied this) nor whether they geniuely accept Islam or not (or consider themselves true muslims according to commonly held teachings or not or even aspire to be), they just refuse to lose the fruits of women's liberalization. So what do you think about this issue for instance?