Yes, probably worth assigning both! A key upshot from the reply: "while Barnett is correct to assert that Brennan’s assumption of voter independence is unrealistic, our criticism of Barnett’s use of Partial Unimodality—somewhat ironically—shows that Barnett, too, falls prey to a rather similar (if less acute and conclusive) flaw."
Yes, probably worth assigning both! A key upshot from the reply: "while Barnett is correct to assert that Brennan’s assumption of voter independence is unrealistic, our criticism of Barnett’s use of Partial Unimodality—somewhat ironically—shows that Barnett, too, falls prey to a rather similar (if less acute and conclusive) flaw."
Yes, probably worth assigning both! A key upshot from the reply: "while Barnett is correct to assert that Brennan’s assumption of voter independence is unrealistic, our criticism of Barnett’s use of Partial Unimodality—somewhat ironically—shows that Barnett, too, falls prey to a rather similar (if less acute and conclusive) flaw."